The Crate Conversation the Dog World Needs to Have

The Crate Debate

Dog crates spark strong opinions—some see them as helpful tools, while others worry about cruelty. The key is how they’re used. When done right, crates offer security and structure; when misused, they can cause stress.

Let’s break it down.

The Benefits of Crates

Crates help with house training, provide a safe space during travel, and prevent destructive behaviour. They also offer dogs a quiet retreat, much like a bedroom for humans. Used properly, they create a sense of comfort and routine.

The Concerns

Critics argue crates are restrictive, potentially leading to stress or behavioural issues if dogs are left inside for too long. Organisations like PETA highlight risks such as muscle atrophy and anxiety from prolonged confinement. The issue isn’t the crate itself but how it’s used.

Do Dogs Naturally Like Crates?

Some claim crates mimic a dog’s wolf ancestors’ denning instincts. However, research suggests wolves only use dens for raising young, not daily life. The reality? Dogs can be trained to see crates as safe spaces.

When Crates Make Sense in Daycare

Crates help with:

• Young puppies that need sleep

• Dogs that need short decompression breaks

• Dogs recovering from injury

• High-energy environments that benefit from structured downtime

• Short, planned naps work. Long lock-ins do not.

The Bottom Line

Crates aren’t inherently good or bad—it’s all about responsible use. When introduced positively and used in moderation, they can be an effective tool for training and safety. At Duncan’s Dog Co, our approach ensures crates enhance a dog’s well-being rather than restrict it.

Do you use crates for your dog? Share your thoughts in the comments!